COVID-19 Antibody Testing: Pros & Cons

Many people are interested in finding out if they were previously infected with COVID-19. An antibody test (now more widely available) can provide that answer. But before you run out to get the test, it’s important to understand the pros and cons.

What is antibody testing?

Antibody testing (also referred to as serological testing) is a blood test that can detect if you were previously infected with COVID-19. The presence of specific antibodies suggests that you have been exposed and your body developed the blood proteins needed to fight the infection. The antibody test may not be able to show current presence of the virus (like you might experience with a nasal or throat swab test) because it can take 1-3 weeks to develop antibodies after symptoms occur.

Pros:
There are a few ways antibody testing can be valuable:

  • To know your status: Research suggests that many who are infected COVID-19 show no or mild signs and symptoms of illness, so antibody tests could be useful in determining if you had it without knowing. Antibody test results could also help guide your doctor in making clinical decisions about your care.
  • To understand disease prevalence: Widespread antibody testing could give researchers a better understanding of how many people have been infected and how deadly the virus really is. Researchers can use this data to predict how COVID-19 might affect us in the future, including why some people are more severely impacted than others.
  • For convalescent plasma therapy: Convalescent plasma therapy uses the blood and antibodies from recovered COVID-19 patients to help treat others with COVID-19. Hackensack University Medical Center’s convalescent plasma therapy clinical trial, for example, uses the blood of COVID-19 survivors who have a very large presence of antibodies. Testing is needed to make this determination.
  • To help develop a vaccine: When a vaccine is developed, it imitates a certain infection, and once injected, it helps build up the body’s natural defense against the infection, creating immunity to the disease. Part of that defense includes the production of antibodies. Testing is needed to verify the body’s response to a potential vaccine.

Cons:
There are three main concerns with antibody testing:

  • Quality: There are several different antibody tests for COVID-19. Some perform better than others, and most tests are still being evaluated by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Some things to consider: It is possible to be exposed to COVID-19 and not develop antibodies. With low quality tests, it is also possible to receive a “false positive” because you had another type of virus.
  • False Sense of Immunity: Some people think having COVID-19 antibodies means they are immune to the virus and won’t catch it again. There is currently no evidence to suggest that people who have recovered from COVID-19 are immune to catching it again. Until more research is done, you should still take proper precautions to prevent further spread of the virus if you receive a positive COVID-19 antibody test result.
  • Active Infections: If you test negative for COVID-19 antibodies, it doesn’t rule out the chance that you could have an active infection and haven’t built up the antibodies against it yet. This means that you could be spreading the virus to others without knowing it.

Where can I get an antibody test for COVID-19?

If you feel like antibody testing is right for you, you can get testing done at Mountainside Medical Center COVID-19 testing site. You must have a prescription from a Mountainside Medical Group provider.

Make a telemedicine appointment with a Mountainside Medical Group Provider to be evaluated for candidacy, including having no current signs or symptoms of COVID-19.

How are antibody tests performed?

Antibody tests are blood tests that are either conducted by a finger prick or blood draw. The blood is then inspected for two types of antibodies: IgM (which develop early on in an infection) and IgG (which are more likely to be detected after you’ve recovered). If IgG is detected, it is more likely that you’ve built up some immunity than if IgM alone was detected.

IgM tests are rapid (and taken by finger prick) and results will be available in 10-15 minutes. IgG test results require blood to be drawn and need to be sent to a lab. IgG tests can take up to 7 days to get results. We are only providing IgG blood draw tests because it is more reliable and accurate than IgM rapid tests.

Next Steps & Resources

  • Make virtual care appointment with a Mountainside Medical Group provider to see if you are a candidate for COVID-19 antibody testing. If you are a candidate, you will receive a prescription for testing, and instructions on how to make your appointment at our testing location.
  • If you think you currently have COVID-19, here’s what you should do.
  • If you want to learn more about testing, the CDC shares information about antibody tests and viral tests.

Hackensack Meridian Health
Mountainside Medical Center

One Bay Avenue
Montclair, NJ 07042

Call us: (973) 429-6000